armchairgm
all sports, all you
+ Add Friends
You are not logged-in.
Sign Up - Log In
Main Page
Sports
Write
Articles
Hot Links
Images
Meet People
Fun
Explore
MLB - NFL - NBA - NHL - College Basketball - College Football - Soccer - Nascar - Other
Article - Locker Room Discussion
All Articles - New Articles - Today's Articles
Submit a Link - Approve Links
Picture Game - Ratings - Polls - Pick Game - Quiz Game - Spring Silliness
Random Page - Random Image - Random Fan
Edit
Page history Discuss pageWhat links here

Favre and Clemens: You’re Not Fooling Anyone

14
Vote

(See TheSportsFan.Tv for other interesting articles)

I don’t know who Brett Favre and Roger Clemens think they’re fooling, but it is really driving me crazy that they are putting the fans, their prospective teams, and the media through such an unnecessary circus.

Let’s face it. Both of them want to come back. If they didn’t want to come back, they would have retired months ago - Clemens after taking Houston to the World Series, and Favre after suffering through a miserable season. How many times do you see athletes of their stature (that can still play) contemplate retirement this long? Never. Athletes usually reach a point where they either have no more passion or cannot compete anymore and call it quits without creating such a circus. See John Elway, Dan Marino, Tony Gwynn and Mark McGwire (albeit in McGwire’s case because he wanted to get out before the steroid issue hit full stride). At the point of both Favre and Clemens’ careers, if you don’t have the passion and desire to play, you don’t even think about playing. So it can be said with certainty that they want to play. So come out and say it, guys!

Clemens obviously is waiting for May 1st (the 1st day he can sign with the Astros). If he feels the Astros are competitive by then and can sustain a winning team, he will sign there. If not, I really think he’ll sign with Boston. He has said that he likes Boston’s management team and philosophy, and wouldn’t be opposed to playing there. And he even said that a video prepared for him by Sox chairman Tom Werner brought his family to tears.

So I can kind of understand why Clemens is non-committal, but I still think that it’s ridiculous that he won’t just come out and say he is going to play.

Favre is driving me nuts, though. It is obvious in any statement he makes that he wants to play, but that he doesn’t want to play for an awful team (read, the current GB Packers). Maybe if he came out and said that in December, the Packers would have gone out and spent money with the idea of winning one more for Brett. But what does Brett think? That the Packers can spend money on veterans and trade draft picks, and then take the chance that he won’t come back? No. They can’t do that. Favre has put them in a tough position, so they’re taking the safe way: Not overspending on vets so that they can try to build a young nucleus.

The simple situation is for Brett Favre to request a trade. But he can’t do that if he is still ambiguous about playing next year. (Denver would be an IDEAL fit, by the way. Maybe Plummer, Tatum Bell, and a 2nd round pick?).

Bottom line: Favre and Clemens are creating unnecessary media coverage on themselves. It’s clear they both want to play, so come out and say it instead of giving time wasting sob stories every day. Thank you.

See TheSportsFan.Tv for other interesting articles


Date

Sun 04/09/06, 3:01 pm EST

Source

  • http://thesportsfan.tv/?p=165


Comments

Enable Comment Auto-Refresher
Anonymous Fanatic #1
873 days ago
Score 2+-
Why does the media make a big deal everytime Favre sets a deadline for his decision? He has done it like three times and never makes a decision. The media should just ignore Favre until he actually makes a final decision.
Permalink | Reply
ASwaffAll-American
873 days ago
Score 0+-
Anonymous, same thing goes for Clemens. He's set deadline after deadline without coming to a decision two years in a row now. By the way - Plummer, Bell and a second round pick for Favre, a guy who had 26 interceptions last year and is at the absolute end of his career? For a guy that, even if you get lucky to get the best out of him, is only good for one more season? That's absolutely ridiculous, considering the Dolphins just got Culpepper for one second-round pick. As for Clemens, I think it's Houston or bust. He can talk all he wants about Boston, but the only reason he came out of retirement in the first place was to be near his family. Who really thinks he will now move away from his family, move away from his son that is in the Astros minor league system, to play for a city that treated him like dirt the first time he left?
Permalink | Reply
DNLLegend
873 days ago
Score 1+-
To the author:

I think, at least as Favre is concerned, he's struggling on a number of levels. On one hand, he probably didn't want to go out in a 4-12 blaze of ... what's the opposite of glory? On the other hand, there's no reason to think that the Packers will be any better, and besides, Mike Sherman is gone. Factor in that, for his entire life, he's done nothing but play football. This is a huge decisions for him, and I think we need to give him a pass on his lack of a decision.

Permalink | Reply
DNLLegend
873 days ago
Score 4+-
Oh, and the cap implications of trading Favre would be a nightmare, as would the PR hit. Plus, who would take a guy who, as ASwaff said, is on the downside of his career and has maybe two years left?
Permalink | Reply
Anonymous Fanatic #2
873 days ago
Score -1+-
"who would take a guy who, as ASwaff said, is on the downside of his career and has maybe two years left?" How about like Denver who is a good QB away from being perhaps the best team in the NFL? Maybe my trade proposal is a little lopsided, but it serves its point. If the Packers had a real shot at winning, Favre would be in minicamp right now. His desire to play is not the question. The team is the question. But he is too scared (or hesitant) to ask for a trade. If he did, his desire to play for a winning team would be fulfilled, and the Packers could move on and build quicker (with the compensation they'd get). See www.thesportsfan.tv for more articles like this!
Permalink | Reply
XtinctWaterboy
873 days ago
Score 2+-
Given Favre's recent performance, who's to say Favre is even a 'good' quarterback at this point. The media points at everything but Favre when he performs badly. The fact of the matter is he threw 29 ints (NFL.com) in 2005 against 20 Tds. You want perspective? Brooks Bollinger, Gus Frerrote, and Joey Harrington had better passer ratings than Favre. Would you put any of them in a Denver offense and expect big things? His accomplishments were great but they were in the past which we refer to them using 'were'. He should retire, and he should stop jacking those that care about his decision around.
Permalink | Reply
BMettsSoccer Kid
873 days ago
Score 1+-
The 2005 season was a nightmare for the Packers. As soon as Javon Walker went down it was over, and the injuries to Ferguson, Davenport and Green were just kicking them while they were down. Brett has to know that it can't get any worse, but looking at their roster for next season, I wouldn't blame him for not coming back. The absolute worst thing he can do, however, is demand a trade and then embarass himself by playing poorly somewhere else. Either hang it up, or come back to Green Bay for one last go-round.
Permalink | Reply
Anonymous Fanatic #2
873 days ago
Score -3+-
If Brett Favre qb'd Denver in the 2005 playoffs instead of jake plummer, the broncos would be Super Bowl Champions.
Permalink | Reply
Anonymous Fanatic #2
873 days ago
Score 0+-
By the way, this entry originated on WWW.TheSportsFan.TV. Check it out and comment for more good and straight forward debate.
Permalink | Reply
Bobbyjim45Draft Pick
872 days ago
Score 1+-
I don't think it's fair to compare Favre's situation with Clemens'. Clemens isn't hurting anyone by not coming back... Favre is has the Packers in the palm of his hand by not saying whether he should come back. If he does, the Packers don't need another qb and can continue to develop Rodgers. If he doesn't, they could still grab someone like Kerry Collins to hold them over for a few years. Clemens isn't hurting the Astros or Red Sox by not saying what he will do.
Permalink | Reply
SportsExpert
872 days ago
Score 0+-
I agree with Favre that he wants to play for a winning team and that is understandable considering the Packers have done nothing to make themselves really better and he is upset about bruusing his body and doing it for nothing. He has the right to be considered about his health and to have a desire to win and ask for a winning team.
Permalink | Reply
ASwaffAll-American
872 days ago
Score -1+-
I couldn't agree more with Xtinct. Although it's possible that Favre still has something to offer, I wouldn't give much based on what recent experience tells you about his performance level. Losing a leading receiver is tough, but only so much of that contributes to a 29 INT season. I'd also be worried about his recent statements that he finds it hard to get up for games when he's not playing for a winning team. I'm willing to give a future Hall of Famer the benefit of the doubt on something like that, but you gotta be concerned about a guy that's reaching the end of his career and just might decide mid-season he doesn't feel like playing for the team anymore.
Permalink | Reply
Add your Comment
ArmchairGM welcomes all comments. If you don't want to be anonymous, Register or Login. It's free


Retrieved from "http://www.armchairgm.com/Favre_and_Clemens:_You%E2%80%99re_Not_Fooling_Anyone"

This page was last modified 17:17, 18 April 2006. Content is available under the GFDL.

Categories: Opinions | NFL Opinions | MLB Opinions | Green Bay Packers Opinions | Houston Astros Opinions | Denver Broncos Opinions | Boston Red Sox Opinions | April 9, 2006

Contribute

ArmchairGM's pages can be edited.
Is this page incomplete? Is there anything wrong?
Change it!

Edit this page Discuss this page Page history

Recent contributors to this page

The following people recently contributed to this article.

Embed this on your site

Main Page About Special Pages Help Terms of Use Advertise