armchairgm
all sports, all you
+ Add Friends
You are not logged-in.
Sign Up - Log In
Main Page
Sports
Write
Articles
Hot Links
Images
Meet People
Fun
Explore
MLB - NFL - NBA - NHL - College Basketball - College Football - Soccer - Nascar - Other
Article - Locker Room Discussion
All Articles - New Articles - Today's Articles
Submit a Link - Approve Links
Picture Game - Ratings - Polls - Pick Game - Quiz Game - Spring Silliness
Random Page - Random Image - Random Fan

About the Author

Grant McAuley
Grant McAuley covers baseball for the Braves Radio Network. Over the past four seasons, McAuley has made daily contributions on his "Braves Insider" page for network flagship websites, 640 WGST and 94.9 The Bull as well as MLB.com's MLBlog site.

In 2006, McAuley penned a look back on the 14-consecutive Divisional Titles won by the Atlanta Braves, as part of a 1-hour show, voiced by long-time Braves broadcaster Skip Caray. The show highlights and honors the accomplishments of the team from 1991-2005. McAuley was also featured in ESPN Classic's "Top 5 Reason You Can't Blame," as they focused on Braves manager Bobby Cox in a show first airing in September of that year.

More By Grant McAuley

The Tomahawk Times - Delgado, Mets surge past Braves in 8th, win 7-3
2 votes, 0 comments
The Tomahawk Times - Zito leads Giants over hapless Braves, 5-0
2 votes, 0 comments
The Tomahawk Times - Lincecum electric in Giants 3-1 triumph over Braves
2 votes, 0 comments
View All

Other recent contributors

Make this page better by editing it.

Other recent voters

If you like the article, vote for it.
Edit
Page history Discuss pageWhat links here

Leading the way, Murphy endorses Chipper as Hall of Famer

by Grant McAuley
created May 25, 2008, last edited June 03, 2008
15
Vote

When Chipper Jones drove a Mike Pelfrey pitch into the center field stands for his 398th career home run on Wednesday, the blast tied him with long-time Atlanta Braves fan favorite  Dale Murphy for 45th on the all-time list. Elite company to be sure, and yet another accomplishment in a storied career of Chipper Jones.

Now Chipper is quickly approaching the 400 home run club, a mark which remained just out of reach for the stoic Murphy. In the 43-year history of the Atlanta club, Jones and Murphy may well be the most popular players of their respective generations. And while homer number 400 will be yet another Hall of Fame qualifier for Jones, it's number 399 that will see him surpass the "Murph" in the record books.

Murphy, now 52, visited Turner Field with his son Jake over the weekend, perhaps paving the way for his son to join "the family business." 

With son Shawn drafted by the NFL's Miami Dolphins, it was time to see what the next in line could do with the leather and the lumber. After watching Jake take a round of batting practice prior to Saturday's contest against the Oakland Athletics, Murphy had high praise for the man who was then closing in on his spot on the home run leaderboard.

"I knew it was a matter of time before all that would be erased," said Murphy of the offensive numbers he put up over his 18-year career. "Chipper is a great talent and he's having one of his best years. He just gets better and better."

No one questions Murphy's class-act credentials as Hall of Fame caliber, but his statistical accomplishments have fallen into the borderline category amongst the majority of voters. We remember Murphy as the clean living, two-time NL MVP who won the hearts of Atlanta fans in his nearly 15 seasons with the Braves. It was more than enough to earn him a spot in the Atlanta Braves Hall of Fame.

However, Murphy's decline was precipitous over his final five seasons. A career-best 44 homers and a .295 average in 1987 marked the last great campaign for Murphy. In 1990, shortly after the Braves drafted an 18-year old shortstop named Larry Wayne Jones out of Jacksonville, Florida, Murphy was on his way to Philadelphia to make room in the Atlanta outfield for an up and comer named David Justice. The Braves immediately embarked on a magical post-season journey that lasted for 14 seasons, with Chipper Jones at the center of most of those teams.

For a moment, it looked as though Chipper may suffer the same kind of late career decline, albeit thanks to a number of nagging injuries that began in 2004. But those injuries have been unable to derail the former number one pick from making good on all the talent that the Braves saw in him way back in 1990. Moving back to his more familiar position of third base after a brief sojourn in the outfield, Jones has embarked on a renaissance of sorts at the plate.

"Chipper's just a great player," said Murphy, singing the praises of this generation's premier Braves hitter. "He's a Hall of Famer. Switch-hitter, he's smart and he knows how to hit."

His dominance has been noticed by just about everybody this year. Jones is the only batter still boasting a batting average above .400. Chipper's nightly hitting displays this season have put him in line for that elusive batting title that escaped him in 2007, when he hit a career-high .337. 

While we are on the subject of batting average, Chipper (.309) is the only switch hitter in the history of the game to have 300 or more homers and a career batting average above .300. Trailing only Mickey Mantle (536) and Eddie Murray (504) on the homer list for switch hitters, Jones' accomplishments could earn him a spot in Cooperstown one day. That, my friends, is some pretty serious company.

"It's incredible," remarked Murphy. "Let's be honest, he's towards the other half of his career as opposed to the beginning half and it's amazing to get your average to continue [at that level]. Most guys go the other way. Mike Schmidt is one of the few guys I remember that got better and better."

They don't come much better at the hot corner than Schmidt. Throughout the early '80s, Murphy and Schmidt traded MVP seasons, with the two combining to win the award every season from 1980-83 and Schmidt grabbed another in '86. Chipper captured his MVP in 1999 as the Braves reached the World Series for the fifth time in the decade.

Braves manager Bobby Cox saw most of Murphy's and has seen all of Chipper's career in his time with Altanta. He has spent years at the helm in the dugout, beginning with his first stint in 1978-1981. In his final season as the team's general manager, Cox was the man who both drafted Chipper and traded Murphy during the last of the lean years. Some 18 years after the summer of '90, Cox has seen every one of Chipper's 398 career home runs. It's the most to start a career by any player under one manager. 

With his two-homer game against the Los Angeles Dodgers on July 5 of last season, Chipper  passed Murphy's Atlanta record of 371. Having managed them both, few could put it in better perspective better than Cox, who echoed the sentiments that best described the occasion.

"It's a pretty darn good honor to pass Murphy," said Cox when Chipper became the Atlanta homer leader. "Murph has been a legend in Atlanta for a long time, and still is. So I think it means an awful lot."

Murphy is not alone in his summation of Chipper's surge in the latter part of his career. This extended period of hot hitting over the past few seasons has catipulted Jones back on the offensive leaderboards each season, a fact that is certainly not lost on Cox.

"I think Chipper, the last two years, is swinging a bat and playing... as good as I've ever seen him,' said Cox.

Chipper's hitting exploits continue to power the Braves offense this season, as always. Conventional wisdom may have pointed to his decline when the injuries crept in, but Jones has thrown that aside and continued to be one of the best hitters in the game. His resume for Cooperstown seemingly grows each game.

But what of Dale Murphy? Will Murphy one day make it to the Hall of Fame? It's difficult to tell. Murphy is on a short list of the very best players from the 1980s, the last decade before the steroid question really came into the picture. If the stigma of the steroid era starts to keep a Rafael Palmeiro and a Barry Bonds and a Mark McGwire out, there could be a whole new appreciation for the numbers that the ultra-cleanDale Murphy put up. Maybe he will eventually find a place next to Chipper in the National Baseball Hall of Fame.


Enable Comment Auto-Refresher
Manny StilesAAA-er
135 days ago
Score 2+-
Sometimes you just gotta be honest and say "Damn these numbers and statistics. Damn them!" Numbers lie. Dale Murphy was a Hall of Fame player.
Permalink | Reply
KelsdadAll-Star
135 days ago
Score 3+-
Both will likely end up in Cooperstown, and owe it all to the Veteran's Committee.
Permalink | Reply
Niteowl049AAA-er
134 days ago
Score 1+-
It was a shame Murphy who had played on so many bad Braves team was traded before they started their long streak of winning NL East titles.
Permalink | Reply
Grant McAuleyJV Squad
134 days ago
Score 5+-
After I started writing this article, I heard Peter Gammons say in discussion with someone on ESPN radio that Chipper is a first ballot Hall of Famer - and anyone who doesn't vote for him should have their privileges revoked. Well put, I thought.
Permalink | Reply
JuTMSY4Legend
134 days ago
Score 2+-
he wants to revoke all of the New York Media's credentials?!
Permalink
Xman2008Varsity
134 days ago
Score 3+-
Anyone who goes into hysterics over seeing Roger Clemens in the owners box (she's never gonna live that one down) deserves to have her media credentials revoked.
Permalink
KelsdadAll-Star
134 days ago
Score 2+-
I certainly respect Gammon's opinion, but he's not the voice of the majority. Chipper's not getting in with 2200 hits, sorry. He'll need 2600 hits minimum and 450 homers, minimum. If you look at the active lists, there are a handful of guys ahead of Chipper on most of them who won't get in, (Luis Gonzalez, Fred McGriff, Gary Sheffield, to name a few) so to blindly say he will just because he was a Brave doesn't hold water.
Permalink
Grant McAuleyJV Squad
134 days ago
Score 4+-
You are forgetting that he is already the third best switch-hitter of all-time by most statistical indicators. Higher career average than all the guys you mentioned, as well as an MVP award that none of them have. Looks like he will get those 450 homers, but homers are not the biggest feather in his cap. Compairing infielders to first basemen/outfielders in power numbers always leads to a home run argument that simply doesn't hold water - to steal the phrase. There are no HOF minimums, or can you explain to me why Kirby Puckett is in?
Permalink | Reply
KelsdadAll-Star
134 days ago
Score 2+-
I have no explanation why Kirby Puckett is in, or why Bert Blyleven isn't. Pete Rose, Eddie Murray, Mickey Mantle. There's three switch hitters better.
Permalink | Reply
JuTMSY4Legend
134 days ago
Score 2+-
its unfair to include rose in this discussion, we all know why he isn't there...
Permalink
KelsdadAll-Star
134 days ago
Score 2+-
Isn't where?
Permalink
JuTMSY4Legend
134 days ago
Score 2+-
sorry, thought you were mentioning rose wasn't in the hall...my fault
Permalink
KelsdadAll-Star
134 days ago
Score 2+-
Roberto Alomar, there's four.
Permalink | Reply
Grant McAuleyJV Squad
134 days ago
Score 3+-
Mantle and Murray were the switch-hitters I had in mind (which is the article). I left out Rose because he's obviously not going in the Hall - so there was no need in revisiting that portion of the debate, for me.

As far as Alomar - I would not call him a better switch-hitter or even a more complete Hall candidate. He did compile some very impressive numbers, and I think he should go in without a doubt. But if you look at the numbers, his career as an impact player was over at 33 and overall by 36. Chipper is still going strong, perhaps the best he's ever been.

Both these guys are Hall of Famers.
Permalink
KelsdadAll-Star
134 days ago
Score 1+-
I certainly respect your position with the Braves Grant, and even "grant" you some homerism rights, but Alomar had over 2700 hits in 17 seasons, Jones is in his 16th and doesn't even have 2200. And let's not forget the 10-0 edge in Gold Gloves, or Alomar's 13-5 edge in All Star games.

Second base is considered primarily a defensive position, with third base more of an offensive position. Yet, as a second baseman, Alomar has better offensive numbers in certain areas than a guy expected to put them up.

My statement earlier about the numbers he will need for election, or in the manner to which he will be elected has only been reinforced.

And so you know, I am a big Chipper fan. But it's not enough to be in the top five switchhitters all time to be a HOFer.

The Hall of Fame honors those who were truly great, not those who were very good.
Permalink
Grant McAuleyJV Squad
133 days ago
Score 2+-
I do respect Alomar, a Hall of Famer too for sure. I have a great many thoughts about things like Gold Gloves, but none have to do with Alomar in particular. I'll just say that it seems apparent that a great many "offensive" players have been getting the gold glove nod over the last 20 years. Chipper's career isn't over yet, and that should not detract from the excellent work that Alomar did over his career at all. But if you asked me to pick one or the other to go to bat for me with the game on the line - there's no question in my mind who I'd take. Time will tell the story and Chipper's numbers will continue to grow. It's apples and oranges here in my book. He's going to make it, and I seriously doubt it's the veteran's committee that will be calling him up.
Permalink
OvertheedgeVarsity
134 days ago
Score 2+-
chipper jones makes the hall, the numbers wont matter, it is his impact on the game that will leave that will get him to cooperstown
Permalink | Reply
Niteowl049AAA-er
134 days ago
Score 3+-
I know everyone is tired of me lobbying for Blyleven to get into the Hall of Fame but can't see why he isn't in yet with over 3700 strikeouts and 60 shutouts which are numbers better than a lot of Hall of Famers. I am a Braves fan but don't think Chipper should go in before Blyleven. Not saying Jones isn't a great player...just that Blyleven has been ignored long enough and it would be nice if he could go in while he is still alive.
Permalink | Reply
Sj-hypocycloidRed-Shirting
134 days ago
Score 1+-
Blyleven and Jim Rice should both go in at the same time. They were both among the best players in the league at the time they played.
Permalink
Add your Comment
ArmchairGM welcomes all comments. If you don't want to be anonymous, Register or Login. It's free
Categories: Opinions | Opinions by User Grant McAuley | May 25, 2008 | May 2008 | MLB Opinions | Chipper Jones Opinions | Dale Murphy Opinions | Bobby Cox Opinions

Don't Miss

AGM Fantasy Football Update (Numero Uno)
How the Angels blew the ALDS I do not know...actually, yes I do
Watching Sports Is Good For Your Brain
2008 MLB Playoff Picture
October Baseball Means... Arizona Fall League!

In the News

The Philadelphia Phillies hit 4 home runs in Game 4 of the NLDS to defeat the Milwaukee Brewers, 6-2. Jimmy Rollins hit a leadoff home run to start the Phils' offense. Then Pat Burrell (who was 0-for-8 in the series heading into the game) hit 2 more home runs, including a pair of back-to-back jacks with Jayson Werth. This marks the first time the Phillies advanced to the NLDS since 1993. Can they defeat the Los Angeles Dodgers and make it to the World Series? Only time will tell...

Comments of the Day

3 Varitek, Ortiz, Youkilis and Wakefield are the ONLY player...
3 Howie Kendrick sacrificed in the 12th inning of Game Three. ...
3 I always listen to crickets, when I get tired I grab the can of...
2 No I didn"t - nor did I forget Manny... Those guys...
2 No, he"s [http://boston.redsox.mlb.com/team/roster_40man.j...
2 Nicely done, BBB15! My only point: Falcon is last in the AGM ...
2 I was referring to bunting for a base hit, not sacrifice bu...
2 http://mlb.mlb.com/mlb/gameday/index.jsp?gid=2008_10_06_ana...
2 Whitey didn"t suck A) I thought Whitey was fine (granted...
2 Chris Wheeler is lame. And I never liked Andy Muser eith...

Take a Poll

Bigger Statement Win?
USC 52-7 over Virginia UCLA 27-24 over Tennessee

New Articles

Calling all APBRmetricians
1946 Army football team - backfield
Putt With Your Brain - Part 1
Phillies vs. Dodgers Showdown
Are the Red Sox in Trouble?

Retrieved from "http://www.armchairgm.com/Article:Leading_the_way%2C_Murphy_endorses_Chipper_as_Hall_of_Famer"

This page was last modified 18:54, 25 May 2008. Content is available under the GFDL.

Main Page About Special Pages Help Terms of Use Advertise