armchairgm
all sports, all you
+ Add Friends
You are not logged-in.
Sign Up - Log In
Main Page
Sports
Write
Articles
Hot Links
Images
Meet People
Fun
Explore
MLB - NFL - NBA - NHL - College Basketball - College Football - Soccer - Nascar - Other
Article - Locker Room Discussion
All Articles - New Articles - Today's Articles
Submit a Link - Approve Links
Picture Game - Ratings - Polls - Pick Game - Quiz Game - Spring Silliness
Random Page - Random Image - Random Fan

About the Author

LouGehrig
I have been a Yankees fan for many years. Thanks to what has occurred during the last few years, I am beginning to wonder.

More By LouGehrig

Batting Second, Number 7, Mickey Mantle, Number 7
7 votes, 1 comment
Joe DiMaggio was Better Than Mickey Mantle
10 votes, 8 comments
Mantle, Rose, and Giambi: Hutch Award Winners
8 votes, 1 comment
View All

Other recent voters

If you like the article, vote for it.
Edit
Page history Discuss pageWhat links here

Hank Steinbrenner Has It Backwards: It's NOT the Designated Hitter Rule

by LouGehrig
created June 18, 2008, last edited June 20, 2008
16
Vote

by Harold Friend (Lou Gehrig)

Hank Steinbrenner is upset that Chien-Ming Wang was injured running the bases in a game against the Astros, as are other members of the Yankees’ universe. Hank is right to be upset, but blaming the fact that the National League is the only major league that plays baseball according to traditional rules for Wang’s injury is plain wrong. The reason is inter-league play.


The National League Refused the Designated Hitter Rule


The American League decided to change its games when it implemented the designated hitter rule in 1973. The National League opted to continue playing the game as it had been played. Every position player batted. The designated hitter rule was not applied in the World Series until 1976, when it was decided that the designated hitter rule would be used in the World Series in alternate years. Starting in 1986, the designated hitter would be used in World Series games hosted by the American League representative.


Interleague Play Starts

In 1997, the owners’ greed resulted in interleague play, which brings us back to Mr. Steinbrenner. Without interleague play, the only time one of the Yankees’ pitchers would have to bat would be in the World Series. Since 2003, it is a problem that the Yankees have not faced, but one never knows about the future. There is little doubt that the Yankees would be pleased to have their pitchers bat in the World Series.


Problems With Interleague Play

Interleague play has caused many problems. A few seasons ago, the Indians played the Yankees nine times, while their division rival Chicago played the Yankees only six times. Central Division Houston played Texas six times, which is the same number of time they played the Western Division Diamondbacks, Giants, Dodgers, and Rockies. Houston was the only National League Central team to play Texas. In a little more than a week, the Yankees and Mets will play a day-night doubleheader in two different ballparks, an abhorrence caused by a rain out the first time the two teams were scheduled. The teams will play in the afternoon at Yankee Stadium and then play a night game in Flushing.


Both Leagues Must Play Under the Same Rules

Mr. Steinbrenner is correct on one count. Both leagues must play under the same rules. The problem is that he and the other American league moguls have it backwards, because, contrary to Mr. Steinbrenner’s stating “Don't give me that traditionalist crap,” that “traditionalist crap” might have prevented Wang’s injury. The solution is NOT for the National League to ruin its game. The solution is for the American League to abolish the designated hitter rule. It would require pitchers like Chien-Ming Wang to bat, run the bases, and not feel as if they are in foreign land when they are awaiting their turn at bat. Of course, that is an unrealistic suggestion because fans love offense, offense increases profits, and few teams are as offensive as the one that run by Mr. Steinbrenner and his crew.


References:


[http:// Hank Steinbrenner's Rant]


[http:// Interleague Play Problems]


Enable Comment Auto-Refresher
False ProphetAll-Star
155 days ago
Score 4+-
welcome back Lou Gherig. Nice article
Permalink | Reply
LouGehrigVarsity Captain
155 days ago
Score 2+-
Thanks. On both counts.
Permalink | Reply
Niteowl049AAA-er
155 days ago
Score 1+-
Another thing is that AL pitchers can hit batters all they want while playing AL teams because they never bat.
Permalink | Reply
CheezerMajor Leaguer
155 days ago
Score 1+-
Let Pitchers Hit This user is a Ban the Designated Hitter fan.
Permalink | Reply
Sj-hypocycloidRed-Shirting
155 days ago
Score 2+-
The only thing wrong with the NL not having the DH is that they don't seem to encourage the pitchers to bat. I don't understand why pitchers are willing to be such liabilities to themselves. At least learn to put down a decent bunt. They should all take BP in my humble opinion.
Permalink
Manny StilesMajor Leaguer
155 days ago
Score 1+-
Nice article.

However, you won't change my mind... I say IF the pitchers can hit, let 'em swing away... but since most of them suck at hitting, I say...


DH Long Live the
Designated Hitter!!!
Permalink | Reply
Manny StilesMajor Leaguer
155 days ago
Score 0+-
But Hank is DEFINITELY backwards...
Permalink
FrugolfVarsity Captain
155 days ago
Score 0+-
Good article but it's not going to change.The DH is here to stay . There is a solution however.Allow designated runners in the interleague games.The pitchers would still have to bat but when they are lucky enough to reach base, take them out of harms way.
Permalink | Reply
Sj-hypocycloidRed-Shirting
155 days ago
Score 1+-
Charley Finley? Is that you? Or is that Herb Washington? :-)
Permalink
LouGehrigVarsity Captain
155 days ago
Score 0+-
As Joe Girardi said, pitchers are supposed to be athletes and they must not be exempt from certain parts of the game.

In the 1950s and 1960s, Mel Allen, Phil Rizzuto, Chuck Thompson, and Ralph Kiner, among others, told me and millions of others that pitchers didn't make the big leagues because of their hitting or running abilities. They made it because they could pitch.

There have been many good hitting pitchers besides Babe Ruth and Rick Ankiel. Newcombe, Bearden, Lemon, Drysdale, Ferrell, and Hampton are among them.
Permalink | Reply
IbeargRed-Shirting
155 days ago
Score 2+-
Am i the only one here who would rather watch ortiz, matsui, thome, etc hitter rather then a bunch of pitchers who either A) don't care about hitting or B) simply can't do it?
Permalink | Reply
JuTMSY4Legend
155 days ago
Score 0+-
well, that's the rationalization behind the DH... then again, when the pitcher bats, it certainly adds some strategy to the game (AKA pinch hitting and double switches)
Permalink
Steel TownAll-American
155 days ago
Score 0+-
Why stop at a DH for the Pitcher. How about we do it just like football and have offensive and defensive units. 9 DH's and 9 fielders. That way we don't have to see any poor hitting players ever.
Permalink
LouGehrigVarsity Captain
155 days ago
Score 0+-
I would rather wait to see what a manager does in the seventh inning when he is trailing 1-0, has the bases loaded with two outs, and has his pitcher scheduled to bat with a tired bullpen.
Permalink
IbeargRed-Shirting
155 days ago
Score 0+-
i'll assume that's a sarcastic swipe at my comment steel town and i'll say this... position players have two jobs: hitting and fielding, pitchers have two jobs in the AL: pitching and fielding, there's really no need to give them a third job.

As for your comment Lou: how often does that situation honestly arise? 1-0 games in the 7th where your starting pitcher is still in the game?

I'll still take watching three battles between pitchers and a professional hitter like matsui every game over 3 failing debacles of an AB by a pitcher followed by some "inspired" managing.
Permalink
KelsdadAll-Star
155 days ago
Score 0+-
Closer: Pitchers equivalent of the DH
Permalink | Reply
LouGehrigVarsity Captain
155 days ago
Score 0+-
Howdy, Kelsdad. The difference is that having a closer has always been possible. No rule changes are necessary.
Permalink
KelsdadAll-Star
155 days ago
Score 0+-
Gee, thanks Lou.
Permalink | Reply
LouGehrigVarsity Captain
155 days ago
Score 0+-
Anytime.
Permalink
Anonymous Fanatic #1
155 days ago
Score 0+-
I don't think the DH is here to stay. What if MLB told the Players Union: we'll add two more teams IF we phase out the designated hitter over five years. Don't know how people watch baseball with the DH. I guess that's the operative word -- watch. You sure don't have to think very much.
Permalink | Reply
Marconi85Soccer Kid
154 days ago
Score 0+-
Good point. Games become watching, not living the games, not breathing in the excitement.
Permalink
KelsdadAll-Star
154 days ago
Score 0+-
They won't add teams, they'll add a roster spot.
Permalink
Marconi85Soccer Kid
154 days ago
Score 0+-
I agree with Sj-hypocycloid. Why not give them a day of extra batting practice? Or just an hour? It wouldn't even hurt to just let them hit from a tee. Just like LouGehrig said himself, pitchers are athletes just like any other player in the team, so they can and should hit. IMO the DH is often the problem, slow fatties who are just good in hitting.
Permalink | Reply
Add your Comment
ArmchairGM welcomes all comments. If you don't want to be anonymous, Register or Login. It's free
Categories: Ban the Designated Hitter fans | Designated Hitter fans | Opinions | Opinions by User LouGehrig | June 18, 2008 | June 2008 | MLB Opinions | Yankees Opinions | Hank Steinbrenner Opinions | Chien-Ming Wang Opinions | Designated Hitter Opinions | Interleague Play. Opinions

Don't Miss

Random ramblings for fantasy baseball
Walker's Rants Bring on the Arctic Winds
What a Difference a Year Makes
Matt's A-Z of Funny Sports Names: NCAA Edition
The State of Seattle

In the News

Hey ArmchairGM users! Want to help the admins update this news section? Click here to help us out.

Comments of the Day

4 This IS fanhood.
2 Dan Lewis?
2 Right now you "miss" it. Once you are married it will becom...
1 No, but Tyrone Briggs would.
1 Kels, I believe your AF is from Fairfield, CT.

Play the Picture Game

Better Basketball Movie

New Articles

Week 12 Defense/Special Teams Fantasy Football Rankings
Week 12 TE Fantasy Football Rankings
Bruins slice the Sabres
Bruins vs. Sabres Preview
Week 12 WR Fantasy Footbal Rankings

Retrieved from "http://armchairgm.wikia.com/Article:Hank_Steinbrenner_Has_It_Backwards:_It%27s_NOT_the_Designated_Hitter_Rule"

This page was last modified 15:25, 18 June 2008. Content is available under the GFDL.

Main Page About Special Pages Help Terms of Use Advertise