armchairgm
all sports, all you
+ Add Friends
You are not logged-in.
Sign Up - Log In
Main Page
Sports
Write
Articles
Hot Links
Images
Meet People
Fun
Explore
MLB - NFL - NBA - NHL - College Basketball - College Football - Soccer - Nascar - Other
Article - Locker Room Discussion
All Articles - New Articles - Today's Articles
Submit a Link - Approve Links
Picture Game - Ratings - Polls - Pick Game - Quiz Game - Spring Silliness
Random Page - Random Image - Random Fan
Edit
Page history Discuss pageWhat links here

2007 Gold Glove Award Winners

34
Vote

by Romiezzo

These are the 2007 Gold Glove Award Winners. There are 10 players who have won their first, while one guy who broke the record for the most Gold Gloves won in a career (17 by Greg Maddux). Congratulations to the following 19 (yes, 19, not 18, as there are 4 outfielders for the National League who won a Gold Glove Award) for their amazing defensive performances.

American League:

Pitcher:

Johan Santana:

I guess his amazing pitching isn't the only thing that teams should look at when watching Santana. He did extremely well as a fielder this year, not commtting any errors this season, as well as collecting 26 assists in 219 innings. He is the first Minnesota pitcher to win the Rawlings award since Jim Kaat in 34 years ago. Trust me, his defense is definitely coming around: 1 error in the past two years? That's really something.

Catcher:

Ivan Rodriguez:

Is there a better defensive catcher than Pudge Rodriguez? He's just that good. This is his 13th award, which is still a record for the most by a catcher. He finished with 19 runners thrown out compared to 47 bases stolen, for a caught-stealing percentage of 28.8. It was a drop from the 45.7 percentage he posted in 2006, and it ranked fourth among American League catchers. He is 36 years old, and still feels young, and I'm sure he'll continue to be the top defensive catcher for the next couple of years.

First Base:

Kevin Youkilis:

Can you say perfect? That's the only word you can describe Kevin Youkilis when it comes to defense at first base. Even though he committed an error in the playoffs, it doesn't matter; it's all about the regular season when it comes to GGs. Going into the 2008, Youk will come into the game as an errorless man (at first base) in 190 consecutive games. Steve Garvey holds the all-time Major League record of 193 consecutive errorless games at first, from June 26, 1983-April 14, 1985. Youkilis needs just four more games to break that record in April of next year.Youkilis made no errors at first base this season in 1,080 total chances and recorded 990 putouts for the Red Sox.

Second Base:

Placido Polanco:

Here is another pefect defensive player, only this time at second base. Mark Grudzielanek was able to do it last year, but it ain't easy to accomplish. No other second baseman with at least 100 starts this past season committed less than five miscues. Along with an errorless season with 683 total chances at second base, he helped turn 101 double plays for Detroit.

Third Base:

Adrian Beltre:

Eric Chavez has been a great third baseman throughout his entire career, and he can prove it to you since he won (a pretty impressive) 6 consecutive awards. Due to injury, someone else had to win it though. Is it Mike Lowell? Nope. Even though he turned 34 double plays as well as ranking near the top in both zone factor (.778) and total chances (384), Adrian Beltre did awesome this year. Who, except for a Mariners fan (possibly), would've thought Beltre would've won it? This is his first Gold Glove award. He finished with a range factor of 2.78 (better than Mike Lowell's 2.40), and fielding percentage of .958, and 24 double plays.

Shortstop:

Orlando Cabrera:

WOW, it's not Derek Jeter. I guess he put up pretty good defensive numbers, huh? Cabrera was able to lead all qualified AL shortstops with a .983 fielding percentage and a league-low 11 errors. On top of that, he was involved in 104 double plays with a range factor of 4.27 (compare that to the average 3.97). I'm sure we're going to see a lot of competition between Cabrera and Jeter for the Gold Glove for the next couple of years.

Outfield:

Torii Hunter:

I'm sure you would've put him on the list. He and Ichiro are almost shoe-ins for this award, but they still earn the award, and make it look easy. Hunter only committed two errors for a .995 fielding percentage, and turned in his usual share of higlight reel catches, which turned out to be good for his 7th consecutive award.

Grady Sizemore:

There is no question that Cleveland's 25-year-old leadoff hitter would get a spot for this award. Known for his amazing range and diving catches, Sizemore made just two errors in center field for the Tribe, and also finished with a .995 fielding percentage, 399 putouts and his 1,409 2/3 innings were the most logged by any AL center fielder. With Sizemore becoming a Gold Glove winner, this ended the streak of Hunter, Ichiro, and Vernon Wells winning the award; they all won the award 3 consecutive times (2004-2006).

Ichiro Suzuki:

Like Torii Hunter, this is his 7th consecutive Gold Glove award. Committing only one error with 424 putouts (most in AL) in 433 chances, which is pretty hard to do; this was good enough for a .998 fielding percentage, which is pretty impressive as well. That gave him a .998 fielding percentage, breaking Griffey's club record of .997 set in 1992. He was able to collect eight outfield assists as well, even though teams know that he has one of the strongest arms in baseball today.

 

National League:

Pitcher:

Greg Maddux:

This man is probably the most impressive defensive pitcher we have or will ever see. He is now the sole leader in most Gold Gloves won in a career as he passed both Jim Kaat and Brooks Robinson, who both had 16 each. A special congratulations should be given to Maddux for such an impressive defensive performance throughout his entire career.

Catcher:

Russell Martin:

24 years old, and already making a huge name for himself, becoming only the third catcher in Dodger history to win the Gold Glove award. He threw out 30 percent of potential opposing base stealers and picked two runners off base. He was charged with 14 errors and 5 passed balls. Pretty impressive. I can tell that this guy is going to be a great leader for the Dodgers.

First Base:

Derrek Lee:

This year was pretty tough to pick a Gold Glove award winner, as both Derrek Lee Colorado Rockie, Todd Helton both did phenominal jobs at first base. In the end, however, Derrek Lee won it. I personally would've picked Todd Helton, but whatever. Anyway, getting back to Lee and his rep, he is still known as one of the most athletic first basemen in the game. He ended up with a .994 fielding, committing 7 errors. He was also 6th in the zone factor category.

Second Base:

Orlando Hudson:

Winning 3 consecutive GG awards at second base is definitely not an easy thing. Heck, only 17 second basemen, including Hudson, have won 3 Gold Gloves in their career. O-Dog committed only 10 errors this season, which is good for a .985 fielding percentage. Since he moved to Arizona this season, he became the sixth player in MLB history to win a Gold Glove in both leagues, joining Bret Boone, J.T. Snow, Robin Ventura, Omar Vizquel, and Matt Williams. He is also one of only 2 players to win a Gold Glove representing the D-Backs (the other being Steve Finley).

Third Base:

David Wright:

A 30-30 season isn't the only thing that David Wright has been known for this season. He has always been flashing his leather. In his third full season of his career, he was able to beat 7 time Gold Glover Scott Rolen, as well as many others like Ryan Zimmerman, Aramis Ramirez, etc. He became the second Mets' second baseman to win the award (Robin Ventura did it in 1999). One thing won him this award: RANGE (2.71; compare that to the average 2.25). He also became the ninth player in history to win a Gold Glove while hitting at least 30 home runs and stole at least 30 bases in the same season, and the second infielder and the first third baseman to do so.

Shortstop:

Jimmy Rollins:

There was a lot of competition at shortstop this season for a Gold Glove award: Jose Reyes, Troy Tulowitzki, Edgar Renteria, etc., but in the end, we all knew that Jimmy Rollins would win the award. Why? Just in case you didn't know, J-Roll led all shortstops in fielding percentage with .985. and he made 11 errors in a career-high 1,441 1/3 innings. His name comes up for the MVP award, and always gets talked about for all the things he does offensively (such as: "He the first player in Major League history to have at least 30 doubles, 20 triples, 30 homers and 30 stolen bases in a season, and set a record for at-bats in a season with 716), and his defense is usually overlooked. If he wins the MVP award, defense will definitely have something to do with it as well.

Outfield:

Aaron Rowand:

Speaking of the Philadelphia Phillies, Rowand, the man with that amazing play in 2006, has finally won an award. This season, he committed only two errors in 405 total chances. He's the third Phillies outfielder to win the award, with Garry Maddox and Bobby Abreu being the other two. He was definitely a shoe-in for this award this year.

Andruw Jones:

For the tenth time in a row, Andruw Jones is going to be presented with a Gold Glove award. Even though he gained a whole lot of weight during the offseason, he was still able to make tremendous plays and show off his range time after time. In 401 total chances, Jones only committed 2 errors, with 396 put-outs, and a .995 fielding percentage. At 30 years old, he is only 2 awards away from tying legends Roberto Clemente and Willie Mays for the most Gold Glove awards as an outfielder. How amazing is that?

Carlos Beltran:

Last year, Beltran became only the second Mets' outfielder to win the Gold Glove (the other outfielder was Tommy Agee. This year, he has done it again. Even though he committed 5 errors this season, with a range factor of 2.80, there is no way you can exclude him from the picture.

Jeff Francoeur:

This guy is probably the most underrated Gold Glover out of the bunch. He has one of the strongest arms in baseball, and can prove it with the MLB leading 19 outfield assists (tied with Alfonso Soriano and Michael Cuddyer). Francoeur played every game this season, committing five errors in 351 total chances. His range factor is 2.14 (compare that to 1.81).

 

 

So, there you have it. Those are the 2007 Gold Glove Award winners. Congrats to all of the winners, once again. And a special congrats to Greg Maddux for such a tremendous defensive career.


Enable Comment Auto-Refresher
Tmil42Draft Pick
343 days ago
Score 5+-
Nice job, Romi. I'm glad you included an analysis of the winners instead of simply listing them.
Permalink | Reply
RomiezzoLegend
343 days ago
Score 2+-
Thanks, Tmil. Yeah. It took me 2-2 1/2 hours to create the article, and edit it and whatever. So, I'd hope you'd like what I did with it. ;)
Permalink
LASportsblogAAA-er
343 days ago
Score 3+-
Congrats to Russell Martin who has established him self as the top catcher in the NL in his first 2 years in the Bigs. Dioner Navarro getting injured last year was the best thing that happened to the Dodgers at catcher since Branch Rickey signed the great Roy Campenella.
Permalink | Reply
RomiezzoLegend
343 days ago
Score 0+-
Or what about LA getting rid of Gagne?
Permalink
LASportsblogAAA-er
343 days ago
Score 0+-
Getting rid of Gagne did nothing for our Catcher situation.
Permalink
RomiezzoLegend
343 days ago
Score 0+-
Oh, my bad. I didn't see catcher in there.
Permalink
LASportsblogAAA-er
343 days ago
Score 0+-
no biggie =)
Permalink
SashaDiv-I Stud
343 days ago
Score 2+-
Does anyone know which two outfielders tied?
Permalink | Reply
RomiezzoLegend
343 days ago
Score 2+-
Beltran and Francoeur, I believe...but you might want to double check with something else. I just found the outfielders in THAT specific order.
Permalink
ASwaffAll-American
343 days ago
Score 2+-
It was actually Rowand and Francoeur.
Permalink
RomiezzoLegend
343 days ago
Score 1+-
I'm confused. :S
Permalink
KelsdadAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 2+-
Francoeur and Rowand, actually
Permalink | Reply
RomiezzoLegend
343 days ago
Score 1+-
Really? I never would've believed that. Rowand put up better numbers than Beltran did, didn't he?
Permalink
JuTMSY4Legend
343 days ago
Score 2+-
fielding is a terribly subjective skill I like to call it the Jim Edmonds Factor...
Permalink
Bobbyjim45Draft Pick
343 days ago
Score 2+-
Why couldn't they just make up their damn minds on the third outfielder in the NL?
Permalink | Reply
KelsdadAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 4+-
Defensively, their numbers were pretty close, Beltran had three more errors, and played 20 fewer games but their chances were almost dead even. I think playing in a smaller park makes outfielders look better than they are, balls that Beltran catches in the gaps are homers in Philly. Rowand is a good player, but he's no Beltran.
Permalink | Reply
RomiezzoLegend
343 days ago
Score 3+-
Yeah, I gotta agree with you. I forgot to think about the home run distances and the ballparks they play in. Good thinking, man.
K D This guy is a fan of Kelsdad.
(even if he's a Yankees Fan)

Permalink
Tmil42Draft Pick
343 days ago
Score 1+-
Here's the way I see the NL outfielders: Beltran > Jones > Rowand > Francoeur
Permalink | Reply
ASwaffAll-American
343 days ago
Score 0+-
You can see it that way, but it's not supported by the numbers. Despite people thinking he's on the downside of his career, Andruw Jones is still the best defensive outfielder in the NL. His putout numbers are ridiculous, and his mere presence affects the way teams hit and run.
Permalink
KelsdadAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 3+-
Based strictly on Range Factor and Fielding percentage, the best defensive outfielder in the Majors last year was...(drum roll, please)...this guy
Permalink | Reply
Yakob878MVP
343 days ago
Score 2+-
no respect for COCO Crisp oh well i'll take the championship over indiual awrds any day
Permalink | Reply
RomiezzoLegend
343 days ago
Score 0+-
#10 This user is a Coco Crisp fan.


Coco Crisp is the MAN!
Permalink
The PipDiv-I Stud
343 days ago
Score 3+-
Crisp is very good defensively but the American league is deep as far as great defensive outfielders go. His batting will come around and he'll make great trade bait next year for pitching. He'll find a good home and success with another team. It'll be sad because I liked him.
Permalink
RomiezzoLegend
343 days ago
Score 0+-
I still do. I wonder what will happen when Crisp's contract ends.
Permalink
The PipDiv-I Stud
343 days ago
Score 1+-
I'm not sure when his contract ends, but he is a good player, it's just Boston is a brutal place to play, just like Philly and NYC. Being good isn't good enough for these cities. It is a shame because a lot of good players have had careers mangled because of it.
Permalink
RomiezzoLegend
343 days ago
Score 0+-
That is definitely true. There are plenty examples that I can give you. Take the name Bill Buckner for example. Another one would be Mariano Rivera this year. Everyone thought that he'd never come back with anything after the first month of baseball, just because he had a high ERA and wasn't able to save a game. That changed now, didn't it?
Permalink
Hit By a PitchVarsity
343 days ago
Score 1+-
I can't wait until Hunter plays for the White Sox.
Permalink | Reply
TylersaltAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 1+-
YOOOOOOOUUUUUUUKKKK!
Permalink | Reply
Davis21wylieAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 2+-
Tulowitzki, Granderson, and Crisp got robbed. Seriously.
Permalink | Reply
Davis21wylieAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 3+-
Also, Omar Vizquel could have made a case at NL SS. Vizquel, Reyes, Alex Gonzalez, Tulo... they were all better than Rollins.
Permalink
Napoleon15Red-Shirting
343 days ago
Score 3+-
I don't know about the others, but Tulowitzki definitely got robbed. The Gold Glove Award is a popularity contest, not a determination of the best fielder.
Permalink
ASwaffAll-American
343 days ago
Score 0+-
It's a popularity contest, AND votes are based on offensive performance as much as anything anymore. Take Pujols winning last year as a prime example.
Permalink
Davis21wylieAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 0+-
Pujols is actually a really good defensive 1B.
Permalink
ASwaffAll-American
343 days ago
Score 1+-
He's good. But he's not great, and certainly not the best in the NL. They recognized that he was good, but it was his bat that made voters pick him over obviously superior defensive first basemen. Pujols his good, and I'll grant that his defense has improved DRASTICALLY. But he was NOT the best defensive first baseman in the NL.
Permalink
Davis21wylieAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 0+-
Who would you take over him at first? Lee? I'll give you Lee. Helton? Teixeira? Maybe. I think James Loney of the Dodgers is pretty good, too. But Pujols is definitely up there.
Permalink
KelsdadAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 1+-
Teixeira's the best defensive 1B in baseball.
Permalink
JMFlyer1454Draft Pick
343 days ago
Score 0+-
I agree with Tulowitzki. Vizquel was slightly better but barely. But Reyes and Gonzalez were not better than Rollins. It should have gone to Tulowitzki. But to say Rollins is a terrible fielder is preposterous.
Permalink
KelsdadAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 0+-
Granderson is one of the most overrated outfielders in baseball.
Permalink | Reply
Davis21wylieAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 3+-
Yeah, he only [=2007&league_filter[]=1&pos_filter[]=8&Submit=Submit turned 92.1% of balls hit to center into outs], plus he made 85 plays outside of the CF zone. Dude's got mad, mad range!
Permalink
Davis21wylieAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 0+-
Okay's here's a better link. Granderson was the best CF in the AL in turning balls hit to center into outs, and was second to Ichiro in turning balls not hit to center into outs. I think that warrants a Gold Glove, don't you?
Permalink
KelsdadAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 1+-
The only shortstop in the NL with a worse Range Factor than Reyes was JJ Hardy. Reyes ranked 8th in Fielding.

I knew he was a bit overrated defensively, but he flat out sucks.

By the way, Davis is right, Tulowitzki led the NL in FP and RF, his RF was a stupid 5.39. The next closest was Furcal at 4.96. Ridiculous.
Permalink | Reply
Davis21wylieAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 1+-
I'm convinced Reyes' traditional stats are distorted by NY's pitching staff. Zone rating gives him more credit -- he was second to Vizquel, turning outs in the SS zone at an 87.1% clip, with 58 plays made outside the zone. Rollins made more plays outside the zone, but was far less reliable inside the zone.
Permalink
ASwaffAll-American
343 days ago
Score -1+-
Thanks for that. I'm totally convinced that the votes for Rollins were based on his offensive performance. Those stats back what any reasonable person watching him would see. He's NOT a good fielder.
Permalink
JuTMSY4Legend
343 days ago
Score 3+-
did you just say Jimmy Rollins is not a good fielder? I'm not disagreeing that maybe he didn't deserve the award...but to say, and I quote "He's NOT a good fielder. " is just plain incorrect...if you watch him play, you'd realize he's a pretty damn good fielder
Permalink
ASwaffAll-American
343 days ago
Score 0+-
I have watched him play, and not been very impressed. He turns some flashy plays, but there's a world of difference between making flashy plays and making good plays. He's not a defensive detriment, but I don't think his fielding is that good. He gets a late break on the ball, and he's saved by his speed, but he would be a MUCH better fielder if he started moving his feet faster. He puts up pretty good defensive numbers, but there are at least three shorstops in the NL I'd take over him, defensively.


Tulowitzki this year was head and shoulder above everyone in range factor, putouts, assists and double plays. Second place wasn't even close in any of those categories. He got robbed.
Permalink
RomiezzoLegend
343 days ago
Score 0+-
Rollins was definitely an amazing defensive shortstop this year, but I'd have to agree with Aswaff and say that Tulowitzki should've won the award. The statement, "Rollins is not a good fielder" is simply false though; agreed with JuT.
Permalink
JuTMSY4Legend
343 days ago
Score 0+-
point proven...

I never said he was the best...I'm just point out that suggesting that he's not good is false...

and I'm guessing we all agree...
Permalink
ASwaffAll-American
343 days ago
Score 0+-
Well, he's not good if you put stock into range factor. Since it was pointed out that he has a pretty bad range factor, I'm guessing that y'all don't buy into it when you insist that he IS a good shortstop.
Permalink
JuTMSY4Legend
343 days ago
Score 0+-
Rollins was 6th in Range factor amongst NL SS starters... I think the average is a bit out of wack from Tulo having a good year...but by comparison to others, I think rollins beign 6th suggests that...well...he is a good shortstop
Permalink
KelsdadAll-Star
343 days ago
Score -1+-
Granderson finished close to the bottom of fielding percentage. The only defensive stat which matters. Granderson made "85 outs outside the CF zone" is because of the two stiffs on either side of him not because he himself is good. Someone has to catch the fackin' ball.
Permalink | Reply
Davis21wylieAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 2+-
The only defensive stat which matters.

That's insane. That is an insane statement. Crazy, crazy, crazy, crazy, crazy, crazy, crazy statement. Rubber-room crazy. Tom Cruise on Oprah crazy. I hope you don't believe that. For your sake and everyone else's.

To refresh: Errors are a scorer's opinion. Many more runs are lost by players who don't have the range to even get to the ball than are lost when a player (especially an outfielder) makes an error. This isn't new, and it isn't radical. I thought we were past using fielding percentage to evaluate defense. Please tell me we're past that!
Permalink
KelsdadAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 0+-
Do you realize how facking stupid a stat zone factor is? Who invented it, some retard agent trying to get an average player a couple million? What, does some invisible genie go out on the field after every play and draw imaginary lines in the dirt to show "fielding zones?" I can see range factor being a viable stat when compared to fielding percentage, but zone rating is dumber than the save.
Permalink | Reply
Davis21wylieAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 1+-
Yeah, because we wouldn't want to measure how many outs a player records in the area they are defensive responsible for!!! It's not like that's the point of defense or anything!!
Permalink
ASwaffAll-American
343 days ago
Score 0+-
Great breakdown, but I disagree with you on Rollins. His defense isn't overlooked, because he's not that great on defense. A lot of the reason that he doesn't have a lot of errors is because his range isn't that great. For one of the fastest players in baseball, he doesn't get to the ball very quickly. It costs the Phillies on numerous plays. He's also got NOTHING on Tulowitzki when it comes to hands.
Permalink | Reply
KelsdadAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 0+-
I never said fielding percentage wasn't subjective. And crazy is believing Jose Reyes (or any other defensive player's) stats are impacted by the pitching staff.
Permalink | Reply
Davis21wylieAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 1+-
You don't think groundball pitchers give infielders more chances than flyball pitchers? You don't think a majority left-handed staff will face more right-handed batters because of platooning, which causes more balls to be hit to the left side of the infield?
Permalink
KelsdadAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 0+-
You can't effectively measure it, Davis. That's the point. Its just a figment of someone's imagination.
Permalink | Reply
Davis21wylieAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 1+-
How can you not effectively measure it? Each fielder is assigned a zone that corresponds to the area at which the average player at his position can be expected to make a play the majority of the time. Every time a ball is hit there, he either catches it or he doesn't. Over the course of the season, the best fielders are the ones who turn the most balls hit to their area of responsibility into an out. It can even be adjusted for ballpark, so that guys like Manny Ramirez don't get unfairly punished for having less territory with which to make plays. Defense is about turning batted balls into outs, and ZR comes closer to measuring that than any other stat.
Permalink
KelsdadAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 0+-
Each fielder is assigned a zone by whom? that corresponds to the area at which the average player define average? at his position can be expected to make a play the majority of the time 51%? 60%?. I don't need zone factor or range factor to tell me Manny Ramirez is a horrible defensive outfielder. I agree he is better in Fenway but that's because he plays there more. He'd be better in Tampa if that was his home park. Frank Thomas was a terrible first baseman because he couldn't move and couldn't catch the ball even when he got to it. RF or ZF won't make him better, and if it does, the system is broke.
Permalink
Davis21wylieAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 1+-
>50% percent. That's the standard, I should have clarified that. Basically, STATS Inc. cuts the field into hundreds of squares, and records where every batted ball is hit (and whether an out is made). The "average fielder at each position" is just determined by looking at every fielder who played in the league last year at a certain position, and finding the boundaries on the field at which they, in aggregation, stopped turning balls into outs at a 50% rate. You can learn more about zone rating here.
Permalink
KelsdadAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 0+-
I'm stunned, really. Never read it in that much detail. I could write a whole article refuting it, but it's not worth my time.

First baseman responsible for 25 feet? Third baseman 35 feet.

The fact he writes "the third baseman is responsible for an area approximately 35 feet off the right field foul line....
Permalink
Davis21wylieAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 1+-
Okay, so the guy mis-typed. We both know he meant "left field line". Anyway, those numbers were for all of baseball in 2005 at a neutral park. It's likely the dimensions have changed slightly this season, and they change based on the park each batted ball occurs in. Remember that these zones are not arbitrarily defined -- the boundaries are determined by the line at which the average player ceases to make outs on 50% of batted balls. So, for example, in 2005, first basemen on average didn't make the play half of the time on balls hit outside of 25 feet to his right of the foul line. This could be because they were holding runners, or what have you, but it's a recorded fact that they didn't turn grounders into outs 50% of the time outside of the 25-foot-wide zone.
Permalink
ASwaffAll-American
343 days ago
Score 3+-
If Adam Everett is able to play a full season next year and he doesn't win the Gold Glove, he'll have been robbed AGAIN. All defensive metrics rate him as far and away the best defensive shortstop in baseball, and some rate him as the best overall defensive player in baseball. Y'all should see what happened to the pitching stats for the Astros after he got hurt, especially for their best groundball pitcher, Chris Sampson. The numbers are just staggering. Their WHIPs and ERAs EXPLODED after Everett broke his leg. He's got to win the GG next year.
Permalink | Reply
Davis21wylieAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 2+-
Agreed, Everett is the real deal defensively.
Permalink
RomiezzoLegend
343 days ago
Score 1+-
Yep, definitely. He is pretty underrated when it comes to defense. Just look at his stats from last year: .990 FP, 4.57 RFg, 4.74 RF9, 202 POs, 479 assists, 103 double plays, and only 7 errors.
Permalink
RomiezzoLegend
343 days ago
Score 3+-
As far as AL outfielders go, I've heard the names Coco Crisp and Curtis Granderson in this conversation. Let's compare them to the winners.

I would've definitely taken out Hunter to put Coco in. Worse fielding percentage, zone factor, range factor, and POs. I would've definitely picked Coco Crisp over Torii Hunter.

Curtis Granderson is better than Hunter, but he isn't better than Crisp or Ichiro. He COULD be considered better than Sizemore since he a better zone factor, and more POs (hence, chances).

I would've picked Ichiro, Crisp, and Granderson.
Permalink | Reply
BOMBERSDiv-I Stud
343 days ago
Score -3+-
The Gold Glove award should be given out to the player who has the best fielding percentage at there position. If there is a tie then there can be a vote on who gets it. But there should not be a vote unless there is a tie.
Permalink | Reply
Tmil42Draft Pick
343 days ago
Score 4+-
It's not the Rolaids Relief Man of the Year Award. It's a subjective vote that is made based on the statistics at hand and the voter's own assumptions. And I hope that the voters don't make their choices based on fielding percentage alone, which is a worthless defensive metric.
Permalink
RomiezzoLegend
343 days ago
Score 3+-
With what you just said Bombers, if you let a ball go every single time that you think you won't be able to get, you'll have a very high fielding percentage... possibly 1.000. But take a look at guys who lay their bodies on their line, and go for just about every play. That's where a little thing called the range factor and zone factor come into play. It's not all about the FP; it's also about how many putouts and assists you have, as well as the stuff I said above...
Permalink
BOMBERSDiv-I Stud
343 days ago
Score 0+-
Very good point Romiezzo. I never thought of it like that.
Permalink
Tyrone BriggsHall of Famer
343 days ago
Score 4+-
Great job Romie!
Permalink | Reply
RomiezzoLegend
343 days ago
Score 1+-
Thanks dude. I love your short and sweet compliments. ;)
Permalink
Tyrone BriggsHall of Famer
343 days ago
Score 1+-
I'm pacing myself. It is gonna be a long day...
Permalink
KelsdadAll-Star
343 days ago
Score 0+-
Sorry, Romie, I had to minus you there because of this line;

It's not all about the FP; it's also about how many putouts and assists you have, as well as the stuff I said above

It has to be a mistype, because I assume you know what Fielding Percentage is and how its figured.

Divide the total number of putouts and assists recorded by the fielder, by the total number of putouts, assists and errors credited to the fielder. For example, if Jimmy Rollins has 256 putouts, 473 assists and 20 errors, his fielding percentage is .973 ((256+473)/(256+473+20)).
Permalink | Reply